Why tools differ
They disagree because they measure different things. KeepTradeCut builds values from crowd votes, where users rank players against each other. FantasyCalc builds values from real completed trades. An editor board uses human judgment. Each method has a blind spot, so the same trade can look fair on one tool and lopsided on another.
Crowd votes move fast. When news breaks, thousands of votes re-rank a player within hours, but hype moves the same votes too far, too fast. Rookie picks often rank higher in crowd votes than in real trades. Real completed trades show what managers paid, which is harder evidence, but the data lags news and thin trading leaves gaps for rarely moved players. An editor board stays steady and explains each call, but it reflects one view and updates only when the editor works. None of these methods is wrong on its own. The mistake is to treat one number as the market. Check two tools, read how each one builds its values, and weigh the verdict against your roster, your window, and what your leaguemates pay in your league.
This site does not copy values from KeepTradeCut or FantasyCalc. Its rule is simple: publish the method, show the date, and let the reader check the math. A tool that hides its method asks for trust it has not earned.